Skip to content

Carmine's Italian Restaurant - Times Square

200 West 44th Street
$$

Is Carmine's Italian Restaurant - Times Square Safe for Celiac Disease?

Based on community reviews, Carmine's Times Square is not a dedicated gluten-free facility and does not have a separate gluten-free kitchen. While staff are often knowledgeable and take precautions, there remains a risk of cross-contamination, which makes it potentially unsafe for strict celiac disease. Several patrons have reported both safe experiences and instances of accidental gluten exposure.

Unlock the Full Safety Report

Get cross-contact protocols, detailed safety notes, and verified menu intel for Carmine's Italian Restaurant - Times Square.

Open the Sansglu App
DirectionsWebsite

Celiac Safety Score

65
Good for Celiac
Caution advised for celiac

Carmine’s in Times Square truly leans into the classic New York family-style experience, and—surprisingly for such a bustling spot—they offer a dedicated gluten-free menu with attentive staff who know their way around celiac concerns.

Full protocols, menu intel, and verified celiac notes are available in the app.

Unlock Full Safety Report in App

About This Restaurant

Carmine's Italian Restaurant - Times Square is a gluten-aware Italian restaurant. You’ll find it at 200 West 44th Street in New York, NY. Pricing stays accessible, even with the gluten-free focus.

Menu Highlights

  • Vodka sauce with gluten free noodles
  • Gluten-free pasta dishes

Celiac Safety Protocols

  • Staff asked about allergies and brought gluten-free menus
  • Staff are knowledgeable about gluten sensitivities
Gluten-Free Status
Gluten-free menu available
Staff Training
Ask about individual staff knowledge
Dedicated Fryer
Shared fryer (avoid fried items)

Full menu · celiac protocols · safety details

Unlock Full Report

Know Before You Go

  • Fried items share a fryer with gluten ingredients—avoid fried dishes if you are sensitive.
  • Gluten-free orders are prepared in the main kitchen. Always confirm protocols with the chef.
Visit official website

Celiac Safety Assessment

Caution advised for celiac
May not suit high sensitivity

Although staff are often well-informed and take precautions, the lack of a dedicated gluten-free facility and reports of cross-contamination mean it may not be suitable for highly sensitive individuals with celiac disease.

Unlock Ratings in App

More in New York

Explore more gluten-free dining options nearby

All Gluten-Free Restaurants in New YorkMore Italian Restaurants in New York

More Gluten-Free in New York

Other celiac-safe restaurants nearby

100% GF

Nadas

100/100
100% GF

By the Way Bakery

100/100

Bakery

100% GF

Thyme & Tonic

100/100
TAP | 100% Gluten-free Restaurant

TAP | 100% Gluten-free Restaurant

100/100
Little Beet
100% GF

Little Beet

100/100

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Carmine's Italian Restaurant - Times Square Completely Gluten-Free?

No, but they offer gluten-free options with a 65% safety score.

How Does the Restaurant Prevent Cross-Contamination?

Standard allergen safety protocols are in place. We recommend calling ahead to discuss their specific procedures.

Is It Safe for People With Celiac Disease?

Carmine's Italian Restaurant - Times Square has a Celiac Safety Score of 65/100. We recommend calling ahead to discuss your specific needs with the staff.

Ready to Dine Safely?

Join 50,000+ people with celiac disease who trust Sansglu for safe dining experiences

Get the Sansglu App

Free • Available on iOS

Restaurant safety data provided by Sansglu | Last updated: October 22, 2025